In the wake of a shift among young men in the 2024 U.S. elections, where former Vice President Kamala Harris lost to President Donald Trump among voters aged 18-29, the Democratic Party has been seeking strategies to reengage this demographic. On Tuesday night, progressive voices highlighted the success of New York City Mayor-elect Zohran Mamdani as a potential model for regaining support.
Exit polls indicated that Mamdani, a progressive state Assembly member, secured 68% of male voters aged 18-29, compared to 26% for his opponent, marking a 42-point margin. His appeal extended beyond this age group, with a 39-point lead among men under 45. This significant support contrasted with other races, where young male voters also leaned left—Virginia Gov.-elect Abigail Spanberger won by 15 points, and New Jersey Gov.-elect Mikie Sherrill by 12 points. However, observers emphasized the exceptional nature of Mamdani’s victory in New York City as a critical case study for the party.
Housing campaigner Matthew Torbitt noted that Mamdani’s focus on affordability resonated with young men, particularly through policies such as establishing city-run grocery stores, freezing rent for stabilized units, and expanding fare-free bus routes. “Young men just need to feel like there is someone on their side,” Torbitt said, highlighting the importance of clear, issue-driven messaging.
Mamdani’s win followed a recent analysis by the centrist think tank Third Way, which explored the Democrats’ challenges in connecting with young male voters. The report suggested that these voters felt alienated due to economic concerns and perceived cultural misalignment. While not specifying particular issues like abortion or transgender rights, the analysis pointed to frustrations over what some men described as an overemphasis on inclusivity and insufficient attention to immigration.
The report also touched on perceptions of masculinity, noting that some focus group participants believed the Republican Party had better addressed traditional notions of strength and capitalism. These findings echoed calls from Senator Elissa Slotkin (D-Mich.), who previously urged the Democratic Party to adopt a more assertive tone, referencing “alpha energy” in the party’s response to Trump’s State of the Union address. Despite acknowledging the successes of Spanberger and Sherrill, Slotkin did not specifically highlight Mamdani’s victory.
Journalist and reproductive rights advocate Jessica Valenti drew attention to Mamdani’s win in a social media post, challenging the prevailing narrative that appealing to young men required compromising on progressive values. “Mainstream Democratic pundits said we could only win by messaging to the middle, by messaging to the right, by throwing trans rights under the bus,” she remarked, urging critics to take note of the results.
According to Torbitt, Mamdani’s strong support among young men offers a compelling alternative to traditional political strategies. “It shows a path for liberals that it doesn’t have to be about ‘strong men’ leaders—it’s issue-led authenticity that can cut through and fight back,” he said, a year after Trump’s election.
Arabic 
English 